[Systers-dev] GSoC Bug Fixes and Mailman setup in Ubuntu 9.10

Terri Oda terri at zone12.com
Sun Mar 28 17:49:24 PDT 2010


Robin Jeffries wrote:
> Mozilla has expressed interest in using the dlist feature.  They have
> hundreds of lists.  I don't know how many they would move to dlists, but
> they aren't going to want to delete an existing list and reconvene it as a
> dlist.   So that's an important use case for changing an existing (and
> active) list to dlists -- even some testing corner cases; what happens when
> someone replies to a message that wasn't part of a dlist conversation? (I
> have no idea what the right answer is)

I think it was GNOME, but maybe Mozilla asked too?  GNOME is definitely 
interested.

Migration from regular mailman mailing lists to dlists would be *very* 
important for any existing project who wanted to use them.  I believe 
GNOME's lists have many thousand users per list, and hundreds of lists 
-- migrating to newly created lists could be very irritating and even a 
show-stopper to using the dlists feature.

Educated speculation on my part: I think many larger projects would make 
use of the dlists feature if it were available and migration were easy. 
  Enough that it might be possible to champion it as a feature to add to 
Mailman 3.  If we were to go that route, we would need to have a 
migration path for enabling dlists on regular lists, and we might also 
wish to have a path for disabling dlists if the list owner no longer 
wanted them.  That might be getting ahead of ourselves, but it's 
something to keep in mind.

  Terri


To contribute to this conversation, send mail to <Robin Jeffries >


More information about the Systers-dev mailing list